The Dumbest Money I Ever Spent Is Finally Good for Something

I minted, I collected, I rode the bags all the way down. There’s one rational move left, and it took me years to make it.
For about eighteen months, the smartest people I knew were paying house money for pictures of rocks. Not a metaphor. Cartoon rocks, sold as NFTs, changing hands for sums that would have bought actual property in most of the country. I remember the mint-day energy, the Discord servers lighting up at 2 a.m., the certainty that the early crowd would keep its lead this time.
I wasn’t watching from the sidelines. I co-created an NFT collection. I bought into others. When the whole thing was humming, it felt less like speculation and more like standing at the front of something new, a feeling I’d had before and trusted.
Then it went the way manias go.
If you were in it, you know how the aftermath played out. The scale is catastrophic. A 2023 study from the crypto platform dappGambl went through more than 73,000 NFT collections and found roughly 95 percent of them sitting at a market cap of zero. Around 23 million people, by their estimate, holding collections worth nothing. I was one of them. And for a long time I did what almost everyone does with a dead bag, which is nothing at all. You stop opening the wallet. You let the folder gather dust.
That turns out to be the one mistake worth fixing.
Money for Nothing?
The reframe is simple. If you bought those NFTs as investments, the money you lost isn’t only a bad memory. It’s a capital loss, and the tax code treats it like any other. It offsets your capital gains first, dollar for dollar, whether those gains came from crypto, stocks, or selling a property. Losses past your gains knock up to 3,000 dollars off your ordinary income each year, with the rest carried forward until it runs out.
One condition does all the work. You can’t claim a loss on something you still hold. You have to actually dispose of the NFT to make the loss real. A wallet full of zeros isn’t a deduction. A sale is.
I wrote out the full version with the forms, the arm’s-length rules, the grey areas around burning tokens and loss-harvesting apps, and the new IRS reporting that started with 2025 transactions. If you want the complete map before you talk to your accountant, start there. And do talk to your accountant. I’m not one, and none of this is advice for your particular situation, which turns on details like whether you held these as investments or bought them for fun.
The practical snag is the same one that kept me stuck for years. To claim the loss, you need your cost basis, what you paid in dollars on the day you bought, gas included. For a wallet stuffed with tokens bought across two years of ETH price chaos, digging that out by hand is a special kind of tedious. I gave up on it more than once.
A Penny Found is a Penny Earned
So I built a tool to do the digging. It scans a wallet, reads the transaction history off the chain, and lays out each NFT’s original cost basis next to what it’s worth now. The report I could never be bothered to make by hand, done in a couple of minutes. I ran it on my own wallets first, saw a number that got my attention, and figured other people should be able to run it too. It lives at rektwriteoff.com. It’s paid. Considering what a documented loss is worth at tax time, I think that’s fair, though I built it for myself before it was ever a product.
The boom sold everybody a lesson about getting in early. The one that stuck with me is less glamorous. Markets don’t only reward knowing when to buy. They reward knowing how to lose on purpose, cleanly, on paper, when the thing you believed in doesn’t pan out. Nobody printed that on a hoodie in 2021. It’s the part of this whole era I’m keeping.


